...
Post A Reply
my profile
|
directory
login
|
register
|
search
|
faq
|
forum home
»
EgyptSearch Forums
»
Egyptology
»
Of course there were 'Horner' pharaohs
» Post A Reply
Post A Reply
Login Name:
Password:
Message Icon:
Message:
HTML is not enabled.
UBB Code™ is enabled.
[QUOTE]Originally posted by Swenet: [QB] [QUOTE]Originally posted by Akachi: Where the Hell does it say anything about "Dynastic" Nubians in any of this **** that you're claiming?[/QUOTE]^This disingenuous troll sees his claim of dental continuity between Mesolithic and holocene Nubians go down the drain and the best thing he can come up with hijacking the discussion with distractions such as whether or not Holliday explicitly mentioned the word "dynastic". Lol. Talk about a desperate attempt at saving face! What does "between Pleistocene and Holocene Nubians" mean, if not that it necessarily includes dynastic Nubians, troll? Where does it even remotely say "modern day Nubians", you lying jackass? [i]Anderson’s (1968) argument, then, Irish and Turner (1990) argued for some degree of [b]genetic discontinuity between Pleistocene and Holocene Nubians[/b][/i] --Holliday Next: [QUOTE]Originally posted by Akachi: Now as far as affinities with "North African and Europeans" during the Holocene more details are clearly needed, because the Holocene extends from the 11,700 B.C. to the present. None the less the distinction was made by Holliday of modern (who fall within this present Holocene period) Sudanese/Nubians.[/QUOTE]^Now his misfiring synapses construe Holliday's statement: "between Pleistocene and holocene Nubians" as potentially exclusive of, well, Nubians tnat lived during the early or mid holocene, lol. I recommend a comprehensive reading course for malnourished brains. [QUOTE]Originally posted by Akachi: Context cracker context! Take note that this is the bullshit that he must resort to.[/QUOTE]Context? You said that Jebel Sahabans had both West African-specific and Iron Age Senegalese specific-affinities. None of which is borne out of Irish' work or Holliday's work. He noted a dental relationship with West Africans and Jebel Sahabans and that's about it. Holliday never draws the ancestor descendant relationship conclusion your lying ass tacitly brings in association with his work. [QUOTE]Originally posted by Akachi: Ok nice citation, but how does this refute anything that I've argued?[/QUOTE]It refutes [b]everything[/b] you've argued. West African- specific phenotypes don't have dual relationships with European Upper Palaeolithic or Ibero-Maurusian remains. If Mesolithic Nubians have a demonstrable link to either two, however faint or inconsistent, this is a discrepancy that necessarily phucks your whole Mesolithic Nubian=West Africa-specific phenotype ideology up. [QUOTE]Originally posted by Akachi:. They (ancient Northeast Africans of the Nile Valley and the fertile crescent) were closest in affinity to the Niger-Congo speakers. [/QUOTE]Stop lying. Your excerpt only says Niger Congo have a phenotype that is linked to that of Egyptians-- something I've never denied. The excerpt never says the two phenotypes are mutually inclusive, let alone that either is a descendant of the other. [QUOTE]Originally posted by Akachi: You bolded the affinity towards Cro-Magnon but you ignored the statement directly behind which completely undermined those findings.[/QUOTE]How does the observation in question undermine those findings? Watch as total silence will ensue from your end because you simply do not know what the phuck you're talking about, and you will not be able to back your claim up, which we will see in your next reply. [QUOTE]Originally posted by Akachi: Are you so stupid that you don't understand that every weak point that you are trying to emphasis is pissed on by the statement directly behind it? [/QUOTE]Really? How. Lay out what the remains are, where they're from, and the specifics of how the state of preservation of the remains being referred to here, would invalidate the segment I bolded out. [QUOTE]Originally posted by Akachi: So yeah...it is further confirmation of the "Negroid" affinities of Waldi Halfa remains whom YOU cite to have been closest the Pleistocene Nubians.[/QUOTE]This proves that you're a complete pinhead. You don't even understand your own citations--something I've demonstrated several times by now. You don't even know that the 117 site in your citation IS Jebel Sahaba, do you? Why do speak of Jebel Sahaba as somehow not included in your citation? Dumb ass troll. And again, being the retarded dumbass that you are, you cite general negroid affinities as evidence that Mesolithic Nubians had a West African ancestor/descendant link, which is a total non-sequitur. Fallacies on top of fallacies on top of fallacies. [QUOTE]Originally posted by Akachi: You are so fucking deceptive! The "later derivative Sudanese group" that the study that you are citing is comparing to West Africans doesn't have a damn thing to do with anything that we're talking about! [b]What do Wadi Howar (5th to 2nd millennium BCE) inhabitants (Libyan-Sudanese border) have to do with Pleistocene Nubians along the Nile Valley?[/b][/QUOTE]You mean other than the fact that all the skeletal remains I mentioned classify as Jebel Sahaba-like populations? Again, I'm noting the fact that you have no phuchin' idea what you're talking about. You're just making it all up as you're going along. [QUOTE]Originally posted by Akachi: You are so fucking deceptive! The "later derivative Sudanese group" that the study that you are citing is comparing to West Africans doesn't have a damn thing to do with anything that we're talking about![/QUOTE]Lol. Me saying that none of the migrations that went towards West Africa from the Sudan region had the forest-adapted specific phenotype, has nothing to do with the subject? Really? SMH. [i]Patently false. The Mesolithic Nubian population and later derivative Sudanese groups don’t have a special ancestral link to West Africans beyond the sharing of a general SSA dental pattern[/i] --Swenet [/QB][/QUOTE]
Instant Graemlins
Instant UBB Code™
What is UBB Code™?
Options
Disable Graemlins in this post.
*** Click here to review this topic. ***
Contact Us
|
EgyptSearch!
(c) 2015 EgyptSearch.com
Powered by UBB.classic™ 6.7.3