EgyptSearch Forums
Ancient Egypt and Egyptology a new annoucment by Dr. Alsaadawi (Page 1)
|
UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone! This topic is 2 pages long: 1 2 |
next newest topic | next oldest topic |
Author | Topic: a new annoucment by Dr. Alsaadawi |
ausar Moderator Posts: 3233 |
posted 12 February 2005 08:33 PM
My fellow Egyptian friend Dr. Ossama-Alsaadawi told me to pass this along to whomwever is interested. The english readers might have difficulty understanding this,but those fluent in Arabic will understand.
IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 12 February 2005 08:52 PM
All I can read is that he thinks some statue is of Moses. But where is the article? Is there one? When you click on the picutre that's all you get...a picture. IP: Logged |
ausar Moderator Posts: 3233 |
posted 12 February 2005 09:12 PM
The articles are in Arabic. There is some written text about how Egyptologist know Christianity and Judahism comes from ancient Kmt. IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 13 February 2005 10:34 AM
Yea, but what proof does he have that the statue is of Moses? IP: Logged |
Kem-Au Member Posts: 896 |
posted 14 February 2005 08:27 AM
Ausar, could you sum this up for us? IP: Logged |
Horemheb Member Posts: 840 |
posted 14 February 2005 11:16 AM
How could Christanity possibly have come from Egypt Ausar....Judahism possibly the roots came from AE but we have very little info to go on. IP: Logged |
rasol Member Posts: 2088 |
posted 14 February 2005 11:37 AM
The Jesus-legend is Egyptian, but it was at first without the dogma of historic personality. The Messu, or the Messianic prince of peace, was born into the world at Memphis in the cult of Ptah as the Egyptian Jesus, with the title of Iu-em-hetep, he who comes with peace or plenty and good fortune as the type of an eternal youth. Here we may note in passing that this divine Child, Iu-em-hetep, as the image of immortal youth, the little Hero of all later legend, the Kamite Herakles, had been one of the eight great gods of Egypt who were in existence twenty thousand years ago (Herodotus, 2, 43). This wondrous child, who is the figure of ever-coming and of perennial renewal in the elements of life, was also known by name as Kheper, Horus, Aten, Tum or Nefer-Atum according to the cult. He was continued at On or Annu. The title likewise was repeated in the new religion, when Iu-em-hetep became the representative of Atum-Ra. His mother’s name at On was Iusãas, she who was great (as) with Iusa or Iusu, the ever-coming child, the Messiah of the inundation. Ancient Egypt: Light of the World, Gerald Massey [This message has been edited by rasol (edited 14 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 14 February 2005 04:26 PM
I'm sorry but that's not proof Jesus was created by the Egyptians. I've heard many theories of how Christianity originated in Egpyt (people trying to debunk the religon), but none of it really holds up. I mean yea...there was this spirit the Egyptians worshipped that was the eternal youth and bringer of peace...but that doesnt mean it was Jesus. Nearly all religons have some peaceful person in it...I don't know why people feel the need to single out Christianity. IP: Logged |
Super car Member Posts: 216 |
posted 14 February 2005 05:27 PM
quote: Good question. What makes the author(s) come to the conclusion that a colossal statue of Rameses II, is actually the sculpture of Moses? IP: Logged |
Dada Afre Member Posts: 49 |
posted 14 February 2005 07:41 PM
quote:
quote:
quote:
quote:
quote:
quote:
IP: Logged |
Dada Afre Member Posts: 49 |
posted 14 February 2005 07:45 PM
The stories of Jesus and Horus are very similar, with Horus even contributing the name of Jesus Christ. Horus and his once-and-future Father, Osiris, are frequently interchangeable in the mythos (“I and my Father are one”). The legends of Horus go back to ca. 10,000 B.C.E. 1. Horus was born of the virgin Isis-Meri on December 25th in a cave/manger, with his birth being announced by a star in the East and attended by three wise men. IP: Logged |
ausar Moderator Posts: 3233 |
posted 14 February 2005 09:18 PM
Sounds nice. How can you prove that a legend goes back 10,000 years when there is no writing? Who preserved it and passed it on? My understanding is the oldest legend about Ausar[Osirs], Heru[Horus], and Set all come from the pyramid texts. The modern version we know about actually comes from the Greco-Roman writer Plutarch. IP: Logged |
Horemheb Member Posts: 840 |
posted 15 February 2005 10:00 AM
As a point of information most Biblical scholars see the origin of the old testament as coming from Mesopotamia. IP: Logged |
Roy_2k5 Member Posts: 117 |
posted 15 February 2005 03:19 PM
quote: Highly unlikely. The Mesopatamian religion was most likely not akin to the Abrahmic counterpart. The origin is most likely an Egyptian or African one. IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 15 February 2005 03:42 PM
Have you ever heard of the Dead Sea Scrolls? I notice when anti-Christains try to debunk the religion, they never mention them. It was discovered that Jesus was a member of a sect of "Holy Men" known as the Essenes. He had nothing at all to do with Egyptian religion. I wouldn't be surprised if all that stuff is made up. Did the Egyptians even refer to their Gods as God? Didn't they just say their names? IP: Logged |
Horemheb Member Posts: 840 |
posted 15 February 2005 04:14 PM
Roy...Take any class offered anywhere in 'Old testament Literature' and they will teach you that the literature derived from Mesopotamian religion. IP: Logged |
rasol Member Posts: 2088 |
posted 15 February 2005 04:37 PM
King_Scorpion: You think examining the Kemetic roots of Judeo Christian tradition is somehow anti-Christian? But somehow examining the Mesopotamian roots of the same, is not anti-Christian? Also when we examine the Moses legend are we not discussing the Kemetic roots of Judeo Christianity then too? [This message has been edited by rasol (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
HERU Member Posts: 128 |
posted 15 February 2005 05:06 PM
quote: Christianity and Judaism come directly from Egyptian religion. This has been proven countless times. IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 15 February 2005 05:19 PM
quote: I never said anything about Mesopotamia...Horemheb did. And Moses is even said to have been born and raised in Egypt...I'm not arguing that. Christianity and Judaism come directly from Egyptian religion. This has been proven countless times. Yea, and the Atlanteans built the pyramids. [This message has been edited by King_Scorpion (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
Super car Member Posts: 216 |
posted 15 February 2005 05:34 PM
Judaism as a following after Moses, apparently has its influences or roots in Kemet, where Moses himself appeared to have been influenced by the Akhenaten approach to monotheism. It is safe to say that Christianity and Islam followed the footsteps of Judaism, whatever the differences between these religions. [This message has been edited by Super car (edited 16 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
HERU Member Posts: 128 |
posted 15 February 2005 05:35 PM
quote: If you think it's that far fetched that just shows how completely clueless you really are. Nobody was trying to insult you or single out Christianity. I imagine quite a few of our major religions come from Egyptian religion too. IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 15 February 2005 05:49 PM
This link pretty much destroys that Christianity/Egypt connection. http://hnn.us/articles/6641.html IP: Logged |
Super car Member Posts: 216 |
posted 15 February 2005 05:56 PM
King_Scorpion, do you deny that Christianity has had any influence from Judaism? IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 15 February 2005 06:00 PM
Of course...the jews are all over the Bible for crying out loud. The whole Old Testement is pretty much about them. The differance though is Jesus...in the New Testement. You see Jews don't follow the New Testement, just the Old Testement. [This message has been edited by King_Scorpion (edited 15 February 2005).] [This message has been edited by King_Scorpion (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
Dada Afre Member Posts: 49 |
posted 15 February 2005 06:05 PM
quote: The Africans Who Wrote the Bible This destroys ANYTHING you present [This message has been edited by Dada Afre (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
Super car Member Posts: 216 |
posted 15 February 2005 06:09 PM
quote: Okay. Since you acknowledge the Judaic connection with Christianity, why then is it far fetched that influences from Judaism has its roots in Kemetic religion from the Amarna period. You don't deny Moses presence in Kemet, or do you? Nobody is saying Jesus himself was in Kemet, and therefore influenced in Kemet; keep that in mind. [This message has been edited by Super car (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
Dada Afre Member Posts: 49 |
posted 15 February 2005 06:11 PM
Bible Myth: The African Origins of the Jewish People IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 15 February 2005 06:16 PM
quote: I've heard about this book, and while I do think the biblical israelites were black (as well as many other people in the Bible including Jesus who had numerous black ancestors), I don't believe books that are made specifically to denounce my religion!! And that link I provided gives ample evidence to debunk that anti-Christian propaganda garbage! Okay. Since you acknowledge the Judaic connection with Christianity, why then is it far fetched that influences from Judaism has its roots in Kemetic religion from the Amarna period. You don't deny Moses presence in Kemet, or do you? Nobody is saying Jesus himself was in Kemet, and therefore influenced in Kemet; keep that in mind. So now it's influences from Judiasm? And why would I deny Moses's presense in Egypt when that's also written in the Bible (and Ausar still hasn't explained how that statue is of Moses)? [This message has been edited by King_Scorpion (edited 15 February 2005).] [This message has been edited by King_Scorpion (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 15 February 2005 06:21 PM
quote: Um, I've already stated that I think the Jews/Israelites/Hebrews were black. http://www.hebrewisraelites.org/ IP: Logged |
HERU Member Posts: 128 |
posted 15 February 2005 06:21 PM
quote: If I remember correctly, the first case of a saviour being born of a virgin mother, dying for our sins and resurrecting was Osirus/Horus. After that, there has been DOZENS of "saviours". Jesus is one of them. It would be foolish to assume the tale of Jesus is totally original. IP: Logged |
Dada Afre Member Posts: 49 |
posted 15 February 2005 06:24 PM
quote: Read the book IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 15 February 2005 06:30 PM
quote: Did you even read the link? According to that...there is no evidence Horus was ever virgin born or had 12 followers. Read the book Sorry, got too many books on my 'to read" list as it is. Just bought From Babylon to Timbuktu. [This message has been edited by King_Scorpion (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
HERU Member Posts: 128 |
posted 15 February 2005 06:35 PM
There's also no real evidence that shows Jesus was born of a virgin mother and had 12 followers. IP: Logged |
Super car Member Posts: 216 |
posted 15 February 2005 06:36 PM
quote: It looks like you have point there. King_Scorpion what do you make of the following: Chapter One of The Moses Mystery [This message has been edited by Super car (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 15 February 2005 06:50 PM
quote: Yea, well take a look at who's following Egyptian religion now and who's following Christianity (millions of people around the world). Last time I checked, Egyptian religion was on the list of 'dead religions' along with Greek Mythology. If anything we should be talking about the obvious connections between the Greek and Egyptian religions instead of Christianity and Egyptian (which really don't have anything in common). [This message has been edited by King_Scorpion (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
Dada Afre Member Posts: 49 |
posted 15 February 2005 07:17 PM
quote: Egyptian religion is not "dead". Take a ganders at the language, culture and religions of Africa. The Africans (ie: Egyptians) have everything to do with the background of the Bible and you are obviously shaken up by this. On the contrary, Christianity and the Bible has a lot to do with the ancient Egyptians:
quote: How could Moses write the first 5 books of the Bible and write about his own death? Psalms In The Dictionary of Ancient Egypt, Ian Shaw and Paul Nicholson wrote:
quote: You can find Akhenaten's Hyms to Aten word for word in the Bible. Proverbs
quote: It goes on and on [This message has been edited by Dada Afre (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
Super car Member Posts: 216 |
posted 15 February 2005 07:29 PM
Dada Afre, have you read the "The Moses Mystery: The African Origins of the Jewish People"? IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 15 February 2005 07:35 PM
I didn't read it all, I just skimmed it... Here's the thing...if Moses was aligned with Akenaton in his new religion...then why didn't he say so when he wrote several books in the Bible? Why did he create all new names, a new lineage separate from Egypt, and make it seem as if the Egyptian elite were oppressors in some way or another? Also, a lot of things about what happened long ago will never be fully understood or explained. For the simple fact that it happened so long ago. Which is why I hate it when people don't find evidence and then say "oh, then it must not have happened." Jesus died in his mid-30's scholars agree. He wasn't a flashy man, he was a traveler. There wouldn't be a lot of evidence on him to begin with. There are many unseen and unknown scenerios that play into this when it comes to the Bible. But does that mean it never happened...no. IP: Logged |
Super car Member Posts: 216 |
posted 15 February 2005 07:43 PM
quote: I haven't read the book either, but for the excerpts. However, it looks like the author is onto something here. This would mean that, to really find out for sure, you would have to read the "whole" book. Moreover, Moses' existence is questioned among scholars. But still, there is no reason to disregard his existence.
quote:
quote: [This message has been edited by Super car (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 15 February 2005 07:44 PM
Egyptian religion is not "dead". Take a ganders at the language, culture and religions of Africa. The Africans (ie: Egyptians) have everything to do with the background of the Bible and you are obviously shaken up by this. On the contrary, Christianity and the Bible has a lot to do with the ancient Egyptians No, it doesn't! Some similarities yes...derived NO! And Ancient Egyptian religion is dead...deader than dead. And again...since when do the Egyptians refer to their Gods...as God? They always used their names. Like Osirus, or Horus, or Anubis. They never said God because there was no Egyptian diety named God! You can find Akhenaten's Hyms to Aten word for word in the Bible. Proverbs I doubt it's word for word. Highly doubt it. Again, it's just a mere similarity. What, the Israelites can't write their own stuff without it being Egyptian? [This message has been edited by King_Scorpion (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
Super car Member Posts: 216 |
posted 15 February 2005 07:49 PM
quote: You talk of the Ancient Egyptian religion, as if to imply that there was no such thing as practice of monotheism in Kemet. What do you think that whole thing about hostilities against Akhenaten's monotheism was all about; not to mention what his wife, the good old Nefertiti, had to go through? Are you aware of those developments? IP: Logged |
Dada Afre Member Posts: 49 |
posted 15 February 2005 08:43 PM
quote: Those "similarities" show that the gist of Egyptian religion is not dead. People still worship Isis and Osirus in Africa. "God" comes from Budge's translations. In Egyptian Religion Budge wrote:
quote: Again, the Egyptians have everything to do with Christianity and the Bible. Their "gods" (ie: neteru) can be explained this way ...
quote: IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 15 February 2005 09:37 PM
This is going to be my last reply tonight. Those "similarities" show that the gist of Egyptian religion is not dead. People still worship Isis and Osirus in Africa. "God" comes from Budge's translations. In Egyptian Religion Budge wrote: The similarities are small and moot. It's like pulling straw men on the Bible to TRY to connect it to Ancient Egypt. All things don't stem from Egypt! And I believe God is Greek anyway. The Hebrews/Israelites refered to him as Adonai and something else (I forgot). Again, the Egyptians have everything to do with Christianity and the Bible. Their "gods" (ie: neteru) can be explained this way ...
Where are you getting these quotes from? And no where in the Bible does it say God multiplies himself millions of times. God is God...there's only one. Then there's the Holy Spirit...which isn't really a different form but...(it's hard to explain I'll get back to you tomarrow on this). Then there's Jesus, who calls himself the "son" of God. I will get you some articles tomarrow written by theologans(sp?) on this subject. Now let's look at Egyptian religon...um...Isis, Osiris, Anubis, Thoth, and many other Gods who rule over different things. WAY different from Christianity. And again, they're wording it as if God is one person...and there was no "GOD" in Egyptian religon! So why do you keep giving these quotes on this deity named God? [This message has been edited by King_Scorpion (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
Super car Member Posts: 216 |
posted 15 February 2005 09:52 PM
King_Scorpion, I recommend that you carefully study the Amarna period, before jumping to conclusions. Perhaps then, you will begin to see the relationship more clearly. IP: Logged |
Kem-Au Member Posts: 896 |
posted 15 February 2005 10:05 PM
quote: Did you get this from The Africans Who Wrote The Bible? IP: Logged |
King_Scorpion Member Posts: 141 |
posted 15 February 2005 10:41 PM
quote: Most, if not all of that stuff about Horus is B.S.! Which was partially exposed in the link I provided. I mean he was born on December 25!!!! Get real! That date wasn't chosen for the celebration of Christ's death until recently (whnever Christmas was invented). And I don't even think they had baptism in Ancient Egypt, so how could there be a person who baptized him?! Baptism is a Christian/Catholic thing. There's absolutely no evidence of 99% of those claims. (I was wrong about my previous post being the last). [This message has been edited by King_Scorpion (edited 15 February 2005).] [This message has been edited by King_Scorpion (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
Dada Afre Member Posts: 49 |
posted 15 February 2005 10:57 PM
quote: No I got that off the internet IP: Logged |
HERU Member Posts: 128 |
posted 15 February 2005 11:08 PM
I say we drop it [This message has been edited by HERU (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
Super car Member Posts: 216 |
posted 15 February 2005 11:49 PM
Need to deal with the truth. Remember it's not about making one feel good. Recognizing the obvious roots of Judaism in Ancient Egypt, and hence leading the way for the likes of Christianity and Islam, has nothing do to with attacking any particular religion; it is simply about coming to terms with the truth. It doesn't mean that these religions are Egyptian, and hence the need for them to have Egyptian God, but the foundations of their concepts go back to ancient Egypt. For instance, just a simple reference to Moses background in Egypt, and the insight into revolutionary policies adopted by the rulers (none other than Akhenaten and Nefertiti) of the Amarna period for the new concept of worship is enough for an objective mind to connect the dots. [This message has been edited by Super car (edited 15 February 2005).] IP: Logged |
ausar Moderator Posts: 3233 |
posted 16 February 2005 05:54 AM
Contrary to popular belief, monotheism is not just a Judeo-Christian tradition. You can find traces of monotheism in the ancient Egyptian[Kemetian] religion. There is a wisdom text called The Instructions of Ptahhotep written around the 5th dyansty that details the oness of god. Plus lets compare the traditions of Sheol[the underworld] with the Kemetian tradition of the Amduat. We find also that in many ways the ancient Egyptian concept of the afterlife is very similar,but also different from what is found in the Old Testament.
IP: Logged |
This topic is 2 pages long: 1 2 All times are GMT (+2) | next newest topic | next oldest topic |
(c) 2003 EgyptSearch.com
Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.45c